The Interview
I went to a small library shortly after they opened on Monday morning. I approached the Information Desk and asked if I could have help finding a good book. The librarian was excited and asked me what I had read recently that I enjoyed or authors I like to read. I told him Agatha Christie is one of my favorites and I like that I want to keep turning the page to find out what happens. I also let him know I had recently started the Queen’s Gambit and like it for the same reason. He said it sounded like I enjoy thrillers and suspense as well as mysteries. He is very correct. I enjoy trying to guess what happens before the book ends. Then he asked if I would be open to Young Adult or Children’s books. I told him I like reading any books as long as the story is good. He then asked if there are any authors I particularly like in those areas. I told him I keep up with Rick Riordan’s books and his fantasy writing appeals to me.
Recommendations
After this he said he had a few authors in mind and searched his catalog to see if they were in. He described the authors' books in great detail and gave me reasons why he thought they would match what I normally read. The first author’s books were all checked out but he said Tana French had some that were in. He showed me where they were and said that the first book was out but her series do not have to be read in order. He left me to go find another author he thought I would like and said that if the books did not sound good that it would not hurt his feelings and he would look for a better fit. I read the descriptions of the stories and both of French’s books sounded like ones I would have a hard time putting down. He had given me Broken Harbor and Faithful Place. Then he came back with a Kate Atkinson book and said he thinks I would like her books because she writes many of the genres I described during our conversation and that her books could be for different moods I am in. He said he was going to go look through the catalog more while I looked over the books. After reading the third book’s description I decided it was the best match for me and checked it out. Before I did he asked if I wanted any Young Adult or Children’s recommendations, but I declined because I wanted to go home and start Atkinson’s book.
End Results
Overall I had a great RA conversation. He made me feel welcome and like I was not being rushed to get out. I got help from him for about 45 minutes. He also clarified aspects of the books I enjoyed and why I tend to favor them over other genres. I know from the past few weeks of readings that knowing why a person likes a book and listening carefully to what the patron is describing about the book is very important. Different people can like the same book for completely opposite reasons. I also appreciate that he asked if I was open to more than the adult collection even though I only started out talking about adult books and authors. I am an avid reader of any age ranged book and was pleased he thought to ask about children’s books. I would say it would have been nice to be asked about books I do not like to read and why. I also do not know why he only looked in their catalog. I have a hunch it was because he knew all the authors/genres and understood why I liked the books. I just know that since I am not a regular it might have been smart to look at a RA website. I had a great experience and intend on going back and asking him for more recommendations.
Hello, Abby.
ReplyDeleteIt really sounds like your secret shopper experience was productive. My experience wasn't as nearly as fruitful. It seems to me that this librarian did everything right: asking questions, not singling out personal-choices, knowing what's in the collection. Tell me: did he look like he was busy when you asked for help? If so, that's even more admirable. It's always good when workers (service or otherwise) put the customer or patron first.
Keep up the good work.
James
Hi James,
ReplyDeleteIt was fantastic. I wasn't a member at this library and ended up getting a card with them. He was working on the computer when I approached his desk. As soon as I came up to the desk he stopped what he was doing and gave me his full attention.
Abby
Hi Abby,
ReplyDeleteIt sounds like you had a great experience. I love that he was so welcoming and excited to help. I often feel like a bother when visiting libraries and asking questions. I like that he mentioned his feelings won’t be hurt and he would continue helping you find the right fit if his suggestions didn’t appeal to you. It sounds like he genuinely wanted to help. This is a great way for him to get repeat patrons coming back to the library.
Hi Christina,
ReplyDeleteHe was very personable and he told me multiple times that it would not hurt his feelings if I wanted different recommendations. He also tuned into me liking historical fiction without me ever saying I liked it. I'm definitely going to ask him for more recommendations in the future!
Abby
Hi Abby!
ReplyDeleteI do agree that it would have been beneficial for both you and the librarian to discuss your dislikes when it comes to books. Also, your mention of the librarian’s enthusiasm with helping to select book recommendations is very important in making patrons feel more at ease, rather than them feeling like a bother. I am glad that you had an overall enjoyable readers’ advisory interview!
I am really looking forward to reading the book. I looked up to see all the genres it is considered and am going to use it for my historical fiction book! Thanks for the comment.
DeleteAbby
Hi Abby,
ReplyDeleteSounds like you hit the jackpot! Everything this librarian did was spot on! It's encouraging to hear about librarians that really nail it. I love how he helped you phrase the reasons why you liked certain books.
Also, I absolutely love his comment about how his feelings wouldn't be hurt if you didn't like any of his recommendations. I use similar phrasing in my RA interactions, and it really helps to remove some of the pressure that the patron might feel. As a librarian, I'm not married to this book or author, and I won't be upset if we didn't find a perfect match right off the bat. Let's help you find something you'll really love.
I'm not sure if this was the case, but I've seen a number of my colleagues address readers' advisory inquiries without any resources simply because they're very experienced in that particular area. It's possible that this librarian happened to be quite knowledgeable about mysteries and thrillers.
Thanks for sharing your experiences. I hope you continue to have positive experiences with this librarian and his colleagues.
-Daniel Thurston
I enjoyed my time at the library. He was very easy to talk to and made me feel no pressure from what he recommended. I almost took all three books but knew I only had time for one of them. They were all choices I had never thought to pick for myself but their descriptions made me want to read them right away.
DeleteI have also seen a couple of my coworkers pick books that are exactly what the patron wants without even looking at a computer screen once. It is impressive. The librarian definitely knew the genres I was more interested in so I am guessing he did not need much assistance. I hope I can be that good someday. Thank you for the comment.
Abby
Abby,
ReplyDeleteI really like that your librarian asked if you were open to other age groups rather than just sticking to adult. I think that is a great way to open the door to more book recommendations, especially if you are having a hard time finding a book for a patron.
Hi Darla,
DeleteThanks for the comment! I agree with you. I am a patron who loves reading anything as long as the story is good. I appreciated the librarian asking so many questions to get to the heart of what I was looking for that day. I tend to read books based on my mood and what sounds good at the time. Some days I want to read only kid's books and others I want to read young adult or adult. I think he did a great job narrowing down the options for suggestions.
Abby Abbott
Abby,
ReplyDeletePeople liking the same title for different reasons is one of those interesting aspects that can really shine a light on the individual character. I personally love hearing why someone dislikes or like a book and what particularly grabs them, one way or another. The fairly recent scandal of J. K. Rowling's private opinions have definitely shown me which of my friends find it difficult to separate the artist from the work.
Great discussion in the comments! I have logged all the students responses above towards their class participation :)
ReplyDelete